Bulldog Alumni
| Year | Player | College |
| 2010 | Andy Lopez | ENMU |
| 2010 | Josh Houghtaling | ENMU |
| 2008 | Luis Reyes | ENMU |
| 2008 | Dallas Bollema | UNM |
| 2007 | Landry Jones | Oklahoma |
| 2007 | Payton Kirpatrick | NMMI |
| 2006 | Caleb Choate | NMMI |
| 2005 | Robbie Smith | NMMI/St. Mary |
| 2002 | Adrian Olivas | West Texas A&M |
| 2002 | Jacob Mendoza | ENMU |
| 2002 | Theo Williams | Navy |
| 2002 | Kole McKamey | UNM |
| 2002 | Drew Robinson | West Texas A&M |
| 2001 | Tyler Deans | ENMU |
| 1999 | Mark Joseph | Baylor |
| 1998 | Clinton Greathouse | Texas Tech |
| 1998 | Jose Martinez | ENMU |
| 1997 | Jimmy Hamilton | ENMU |
| 1997 | Chris Olivas | NMMI/ENMU |
| 1996 | Kirk Robbins | UNM |
| 1996 | Josh Whitmire | McMurry |
| 1994 | Ty Houghtaling | NMSU |
| 1993 | Jeremiah Mullen | Texas Tech |
| 1993 | David Patterson | NMSU |
| 1993 | David Joseph | Baylor |
| 1991 | Tim Foley | Boise St |
| 1991 | Jeff Houghtaling | UNM |
| 1990 | Darrin Needham | West Texas A&M |
| 1989 | Cord Ermis | UNM |
| 1988 | Michael McPherson | Texas Tech |
| 1985 | Jay Worden | Colorado Mines |
| 1984 | Robert Johnson | Liberty University |
| 1983 | Thomas Naverette | NMHU |
| 1983 | Martin White | UNM |
| 1983 | Jeff Sanders | Montana |
| 1982 | Scott Runyan | Wyoming |
| 1982 | Eric McCaleb | ENMU |
| 1980 | Dale Cresswell | Southern Colorado |
| 1980 | Alfredo Navarrette | Southern Colorado |
| 1977 | Toby Rhodes | Oklahoma |
| 1977 | Clendon Kirpatrick | East Central Okla |
| 1977 | Jerry Brown | ENMU |
| 1976 | Corey Tolle | Southern Colorado |
| 1976 | Randy Hill | UNM |
| 1975 | Jackie Clifton | ENMU/Wyoming |
| 1975 | Jeff Davis | Western NM |
| 1975 | Jerome Aguilar | NMHU |
| 1974 | Royce Pearson | ENMU |
| 1974 | Johnny Miller | Wyoming |
| 1974 | Cole Boyce | Wyoming |
| 1974 | Larry Combs | Wyoming |
| 1972 | Cooper Henderson | ENMU |
| 1972 | Rolando Perez | McMurry |
| 1971 | Kenneth Tice | NMSU |
| 1970 | Butch Henderson | Angelo State |
| 1970 | Mike Hancox | Texas Tech |
| 1969 | Donald Dungan | UNM |
| 1967 | Jack Vermillion | NMSU |
| 1967 | Gerald Burns | NMSU |
| 1967 | Wayne Mansell | UNM |
| 1966 | Jimmy Joseph | ENMU |
| 1964 | Ronnie Sowell | Texas Tech |
| 1964 | Steve Barrett | Oklahoma |
| 1964 | Fred Malone | Oklahoma |